DEI at a Crossroads: Protecting Progress in a New Political Reality

Among the new administration’s first actions were a handful of executive orders intended to “terminate DEI” in the federal government and the private sector. While those executive orders don’t change existing federal law, they send a strong signal about the near-term political context for DEI programs. Organizations are reassessing their approaches in real time, with some publicly announcing rollbacks and others defending their efforts. The environment is marked by uncertainty and concern.

During a NationSwell virtual Leader Roundtable on February 5, leaders gathered to take stock of all the challenges and opportunities this new reality presents, and to discuss the strategies they’re implementing to protect and evolve their initiatives in a shifting landscape.

Here are some of the key takeaways from the event:


Avoid knee jerk reactions or uninterrogated changes; our current moment demands a clear-eyed approach. This moment of political chaos may be best met with a moment of pause — an opportunity to be thoughtful about the non-reactionary, tactical approaches we can take to safeguard our DEI work and even some of the ways DEI can be more intentionally incorporated into talent and culture conversations moving forward. Although the political swirl and media noise can make it tempting to make fast changes, there is long term value in staying steady in this moment.

Internal assuredness and transparency will have external ripples. Even as many leaders feel reluctant to make public-facing statements about DEI, having open internal conversations about why a diverse and engaged workforce is good for business can have a positive internal effect on team members that ends up alchemizing into an external signal about the direction you’re rowing in.

Explore new dimensions of DEI to create opportunities for shared value alignment. Linking DEI to employee wellness initiatives, for example, can help to ensure that your efforts are being felt by employees outside of ERGs or other traditional forums. Showing that you can create value across multiple areas of the business ultimately serves to make the case for the work and can have the effect of making it more durable in the long run.

We have an urgent challenge around devising language that is simultaneously precise, non-provocative, and inclusive. Nailing the language of DEI in a way that works to further our goals in a non-politicized way without diluting the work at all will be a huge component of the challenge we face in the coming months and years. How do we speak about the work that we do in ways that mitigates risk without signaling a retreat from our values?

Have the tough, honest conversations with partners and grantees wherever possible. The realities of the current political landscape will require honest, transparent , and difficult conversations with partners that work in spaces that have been heavily politicized and impacted by government funding cuts. As always, bringing your presence and humanity into tough conversations about how to avoid lightning rods for politically-motivated actors will be the best way to navigate through them. Creating intentional spaces for radical empathy and candid conversations with partners will help them to feel heard and respected, and will also help to most efficiently surface their needs for your support during moments of turmoil and hardship.

Creating Opportunity: Building Equitable Communities for the Future, a Fireside Chat with Julián Castro

On November 21, 2024, the NationSwell Summit opened with a riveting and in-depth fireside chat between the current CEO of the Latino Community Foundation and former Secretary of Housing and Urban Development, Julián Castro, and NationSwell CEO, Greg Behrman. Although the uncertainty of our current political moment was at the forefront of both the conversation and our minds, so too was this year’s theme, Hope in Action. 

Castro started by providing his perspective on this year’s election results and how we understand them within the context of our work. He noted that across the country, Americans continue to feel the impact of high prices and anxiety about the future, making economic opportunity a critical focus in the coming years. And while there have been questions and even unwarranted derision about the rightward swing of the Latino vote Castro was quick to deconstruct the stereotypes and false narratives around a monolithic Latino experience. No one issue, experience, or campaign addresses that complexity. 

Pushing back on these oversimplified and harmful narratives is even more important in the face of the incoming administration’s proposed mass deportations. Castro pointed to the role of all of us in pushing back against this policy by supporting organizations doing vital legal work in immigration services and civil rights, and by using our voices and influence to demand resistance at the city, state, and federal level. 

“We’ve seen part of this before a few years ago,” Castro said. “And so just as the new administration has experience accomplishing whatever it wants to accomplish, there’s also a lot of experience in trying to make sure that we continue to be a nation that lives up to its best values. So, that makes me optimistic for what’s possible.”

Castro is no stranger to that endeavor, and he comes by it honestly. In response to a question about a leadership-defining person or experience in his life, he went straight to his mother, Rosie. 

“My mom was a hellraiser, a Chicana activist, a civil rights activist,” he said, adding later that “She never pushed us to go into politics, but she gave us this sense that you should get educated and do well for yourself and then figure out how you’re going to do good for other people.” 

In fact, service in the Castro family is a multigenerational project. When asked about what 2024 Summit’s theme, Hope in Action, means to him, Castro spoke movingly about his kids. “Every time I think about their lives, and what they are going through, I think that it’s time for us to live up to our values,” he said, “the values of treating each other with dignity and respect and compassion and trying to find the places where people can work together and compromise.”

Julián Castro lives the values of hope in action, as evident in his lifetime of service, and that continues in his work with the Latino Community Foundation. LCF was first formed in 1989 as an affinity group of United Way of the Bay Area, and became an independent foundation in 2016 with the mission of building a movement of civically engaged philanthropic leaders, investing in Latino-led organizations, and increasing political participation of Latinos in California. And while philanthropy is quite a bit different from his work as a public servant (Castro noted with a laugh that he’d never heard the word ‘proximate’ as much as he had this last year), both feature the core themes that have guided his life so far – lifting up community, and doing good work that makes a difference in people’s lives. 

LCF’s projects and investments are wide ranging, but Castro highlighted with particular pride the work they do ensuring that workers at all levels can share in the success that they help create, and building capacity at nonprofits and other organizations whose leaders often have the ideas and the determination needed to enact them, but not the resources. 

“Less than 2% of big philanthropy dollars go to Latino led organizations,” he noted. By providing operations support and financial investment, LCF bolsters community-led initiatives improving the health and wellbeing of thousands of Latino families across California. 

In spite of the differences over the word proximate, however, Castro sees an opportunity space in the overlap between public service and private organizations like LCF. Recognizing that politics is often a fraught endeavor, Castro emphasized the untapped potential presented by public private partnerships. 

“I can count on one hand the number of times that anybody in philanthropy set up a meeting [when I was a councilman, and then mayor],” he noted, but his advice for the room was to be willing to have those conversations because there are a lot of good public servants out there with good ideas that could benefit from that connection with philanthropy. “We have this opportunity to make a lot of progress when you have stronger public private partnerships because from the philanthropy standpoint, there’s no way, even with all the philanthropic dollars, to make changes on housing or other issues. You need government.” 

Willingness to have the conversation was the running theme of Castro’s fireside chat. Whether in communities of practice that share information and resources, or amongst public servants and philanthropic leaders, parents and children, and Republicans and Democrats, it is conversation that leads to community, connection, and compromise. These are the values that we will need to build a future where we can all thrive. 

But that’s not all we’ll need. “This is going to be a time to be bold, to be in partnership, to be strategic, thoughtful, but to stand up,” Castro said, his last advice to the NationSwell audience. “It’s a time to stand up in [whatever] way you can.” 


For more moments from NationSwell Summit 2024, click here.